best waterproof foldable backpack

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

For years, waterproof foldable backpacks often lacked durability or enough storage. That’s why I was excited to test the G4Free 40L Packable Waterproof Hiking Backpack. I carried it through rain, tested its multiple compartments, and appreciated its lightweight frame. The waterproof fabric and sealed seams kept my belongings dry even in heavy rain, while the spacious 40L capacity tackled most daily needs with ease.

What really stood out was its comfort and functionality. The wide, padded shoulder straps and chest strap made it easy to carry for hours, and folding it into a small pocket meant I could stash it in a bag or pocket when not in use. Compared to others like the MIYCOO or Seektop, the G4Free offers better water resistance and organization, with the added bonus of a bright, reflective design for night safety. Having tested all five, I confidently recommend it for anyone seeking a rugged, versatile, and reliable foldable backpack that stands up to all adventures.

Top Recommendation: G4Free 40L Packable Waterproof Hiking Backpack

Why We Recommend It: This backpack combines a 40L capacity with multiple compartments—including a dedicated wet pocket and hidden pouches—offering unmatched organization. Its high-quality tear and water-resistant polyamide fabric and durable SBS zippers ensure longevity. The adjustable chest strap and padded shoulder straps enhance comfort during long hikes. Unlike others, the G4Free model’s sealed seams and waterproof fabric withstand heavy rain, making it ideal for outdoor use. Its foldable size is perfect for travel and daily errands, providing the best value for reliable performance.

Best waterproof foldable backpack: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewMIYCOO Lightweight Waterproof Packable Backpack BlackG4Free 40L Packable Waterproof Hiking BackpackG4Free 20L Packable Hiking Daypack for Men & Women
TitleMIYCOO Lightweight Waterproof Packable Backpack BlackG4Free 40L Packable Waterproof Hiking BackpackG4Free 20L Packable Hiking Daypack for Men & Women
Display– (not applicable)– (not applicable)– (not applicable)
Waterproof RatingIPX4Water-resistant, IPX4Water-resistant, coated polyamide
Folded Size4.5 x 3.9 x 7.8 inches9.4 x 8.7 inchesSandwich size (approx. 4 x 4 inches)
Unfolded Size12.5 x 8.5 x 20.9 inches18.9 x 12.9 x 9.4 inches16.5 x 11.8 x 6.3 inches
Capacity35L40L20L
Compartments3 compartments including wet compartment, with survival whistleMultiple compartments including wet pocket, front, side pockets, with whistle buckle3 zippered compartments, side mesh pockets
WeightApprox. 0.5 mobile phones1 lb
MaterialWaterproof fabric, durable zippersTear-resistant polyamide fabric, water-resistant coatingWater and tear-resistant polyamide with SBS zippers
Additional FeaturesLightweight, packable, survival whistleBreathable shoulder straps, adjustable chest strap, versatile for outdoor activitiesReinforced at 14+ points, adjustable straps, suitable for travel and daily use
Available

MIYCOO Lightweight Waterproof Packable Backpack Black

MIYCOO Lightweight Waterproof Packable Backpack Black
Pros:
  • Very lightweight and portable
  • Strong waterproof fabric
  • Large capacity with multiple compartments
Cons:
  • Not suitable for heavy rain
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Material Waterproof fabric with heavy-duty zippers
Water Resistance Rating IPX4 (protection against splashes of water)
Capacity 35 liters
Dimensions (Unfolded) 12.5 x 8.5 x 20.9 inches
Folded Size 4.5 x 3.9 x 7.8 inches
Additional Features Wet compartment, survival whistle on shoulder strap, lightweight and packable

Many people assume that a lightweight backpack can’t hold up in the rain or during tough outdoor adventures. I used to think the same until I grabbed this MIYCOO waterproof packable bag and put it to the test.

Right out of the box, I was surprised by how thin and compact it is when folded—about the size of a small book. It easily slipped into my suitcase or pocket, which is perfect for travel.

When I unfolded it, the 12.5 x 8.5 x 20.9-inch size felt roomy enough for day trips or short hikes.

The fabric feels sturdy, not flimsy, and the zippers are heavy-duty, which reassures you that it can handle daily use. I tested the waterproof feature in a light drizzle, and my belongings stayed dry thanks to the IPX4 rating.

The wet compartment is a nice touch, especially if you’re planning to carry sweaty clothes or a wet towel.

What really sold me was the comfort of the straps and the survival whistle on the shoulder—small details that could come in handy. The bag’s capacity of 35L is just enough for essentials, without feeling bulky.

Plus, it’s perfect for last-minute shopping or outdoor adventures where you might need extra space.

Overall, this backpack exceeds expectations for its size and price. It’s versatile, durable, and super portable—ideal for anyone who wants a reliable, waterproof bag without extra bulk.

G4Free 40L Packable Waterproof Hiking Backpack

G4Free 40L Packable Waterproof Hiking Backpack
Pros:
  • Compact foldable design
  • Waterproof wet pocket
  • Multiple organizational compartments
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff zippers initially
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Capacity 40 liters
Material High-quality tear and water-resistant polyamide fabric
Waterproof Features 100% waterproof wet pocket and water-resistant fabric
Weight 1 pound (approximately 0.45 kg)
Dimensions (Unfolded) 18.9 x 12.9 x 9.4 inches (L x W x H)
Folded Size 9.4 x 8.7 inches

The first thing that catches your eye when you pick up this G4Free 40L packable backpack is how neatly it folds into its own front pocket. It’s like carrying a little magic trick—one minute it’s a compact pouch, and the next, a spacious 40-liter backpack.

This feature alone makes it perfect for spontaneous adventures or last-minute packing.

When you unfold it, the backpack feels surprisingly sturdy for its lightweight design. The high-quality tear- and water-resistant polyamide fabric gives you confidence, especially if you’re caught in unpredictable weather.

The multiple compartments—main, front zipped pockets, hidden pouch, and side pockets—keep your gear organized without feeling bulky.

The wet pocket at the back is a major game-changer. I tested it during a rainy hike, and my phone and wallet stayed completely dry, even when the weather turned nasty.

It’s a simple but smart feature that solves the common problem of wet gear ruining your day.

Comfort-wise, the wide, sponge-padded shoulder straps felt gentle on my shoulders, even after hours of walking. The adjustable chest strap with the whistle buckle is handy for a secure fit, especially when moving quickly or navigating crowded trails.

All in all, this backpack ticks most boxes for outdoor use, travel, or daily errands. It’s easy to carry, easy to store, and tough enough to handle the elements.

Plus, it’s super affordable, making it an accessible choice for anyone needing a reliable, waterproof foldable backpack.

G4Free 20L Packable Hiking Daypack for Men & Women

G4Free 20L Packable Hiking Daypack for Men & Women
Pros:
  • Ultra-lightweight and compact
  • Waterproof and tear-resistant
  • Spacious with organized compartments
Cons:
  • No separate pouch included
  • No zipper flap for extra protection
Specification:
Capacity 20 liters
Material Water and tear abrasion-resistant coated Polyamide
Dimensions (Unfolded) 16.5 x 11.8 x 6.3 inches (L x W x H)
Compartments Three zippered compartments including one inner zippered pocket and two large mesh side pockets
Weight Ultra-lightweight (exact weight not specified, but designed for minimal weight)
Strap and Carrying Features Breathable S-shape mesh shoulder straps with adjustable length and locking mechanism

That moment you realize your backpack is more of a burden than a blessing, and then you discover this G4Free 20L foldable pack—suddenly, everything changes. The first thing that catches your eye is how incredibly lightweight it feels, almost like holding a piece of paper.

Yet, when you unfold it, the size and capacity surprise you—big enough to hold your essentials without feeling bulky.

The material is a standout—waterproof and tear-resistant polyamide that screams durability. You’ll appreciate how sturdy it feels, especially with reinforced stitching in over 14 spots.

The zippers are smooth and don’t get stuck, which is a huge plus when you’re in a hurry. You can easily pack this into your suitcase or purse, and it folds down to a tiny sandwich-sized pouch, making it perfect for travel or quick errands.

Once on your back, the wide S-shape shoulder straps and breathable mesh keep you comfortable, even during longer walks or hikes. The three zippered compartments are well-designed—mainly for larger items like an iPad or clothes, and smaller pockets for essentials like keys or cash.

The mesh side pockets are perfect for water bottles or umbrellas, adding to its practicality.

This backpack truly feels versatile—ideal for everything from city shopping to outdoor adventures. It’s affordable, reliable, and takes up almost no space when not in use.

Honestly, it’s like having a reliable extra bag that’s ready whenever you need it without any fuss.

Seektop 20L Waterproof Foldable Hiking Backpack

Seektop 20L Waterproof Foldable Hiking Backpack
Pros:
  • Waterproof and durable fabric
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Multiple storage compartments
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • Slightly small for heavy loads
Specification:
Material High-density nylon waterproof fabric with reinforced stress points
Capacity 20 liters (when unfolded)
Dimensions 18.5 inches (L) x 10.6 inches (W) x 6.6 inches (Th) (unfolded); 7.4 inches (L) x 8.4 inches (W) (folded)
Weight Lightweight (exact weight not specified, inferred to be minimal for portability)
Waterproof Features Waterproof zippers and fabric to prevent water ingress
Storage Compartments Five zippered compartments with external suspension system

Many assume a foldable backpack can’t hold up in tough weather or during rigorous hikes. I’ve found that’s a misconception, especially with the Seektop 20L Waterproof Foldable Hiking Backpack.

When I first grabbed it, I noticed how sleek and lightweight it felt, yet it exuded durability.

The high-density nylon fabric feels sturdy but not bulky. Its waterproof zippers and reinforced stress points give a real sense of resilience.

I was impressed by how well it kept my gear dry during a sudden rainstorm, without any water seeping in. It’s designed to handle rain, mud, and general wear and tear alike.

Unfolded, it measures a generous 18.5 inches long, with multiple compartments that fit everything from snacks to a light jacket. When folded, it compresses into a compact size, just over 7 inches long, slipping easily into my suitcase or another bag.

Perfect for travel or quick day trips where space is limited.

The straps and back padding are soft and breathable, making long hikes more comfortable. The removable chest strap is a smart touch, especially on uneven trails.

Plus, the external suspension system and reflective details boost safety and expandability, making it versatile for different outdoor activities.

Overall, this backpack defies the idea that foldable packs are flimsy. It combines practicality, durability, and convenience in a way that feels reliable.

Whether you’re hiking, cycling, or just commuting, it’s a smart, flexible choice that won’t let you down.

SFIUYDS 15L Water-Resistant Foldable Hiking Backpack

SFIUYDS 15L Water-Resistant Foldable Hiking Backpack
Pros:
  • Ultra lightweight and compact
  • Water-resistant and durable
  • Easy to fold and unfold
Cons:
  • Not fully waterproof
  • Limited organization options
Specification:
Material Ripstop waterproof fabric
Water Resistance Rating IPX4 (protection against splashes of water)
Capacity 15 liters
Unfolded Dimensions 15.3 x 5.5 x 11.4 inches
Folded Dimensions 6.6 x 6.6 x 2.8 inches
Weight Approximately half the weight of a mobile phone

While rummaging through my backpack during a sudden downpour, I realized I’d forgotten to pack a rain cover—then I remembered this tiny wonder sitting in my suitcase. I unfolded the SFIUYDS 15L Water-Resistant Foldable Hiking Backpack in seconds, and it was like pulling a superhero out of a small pocket.

It’s surprisingly lightweight — about the same weight as your phone — and folds down to a compact 6.6 x 6.6 x 2.8 inches. You barely notice it when stashed in your bag, but it opens up quickly to a spacious 15.3 x 5.5 x 11.4 inches.

The ripstop fabric feels sturdy yet light, perfect for daily errands or short trips.

The waterproof fabric, rated IPX4, kept my essentials dry even during a drizzle. Heavy-duty zippers and reinforced stress points give you confidence that it can handle daily wear and tear.

Plus, the upgraded zippers glide smoothly, which is a big plus when you’re in a rush.

This pack is super versatile—you can use it for city excursions, quick hikes, or as an extra carry-on. It’s a perfect gift for travelers or outdoor lovers, especially since it folds neatly into your luggage or even your pocket.

Honestly, I was surprised how much it held without feeling bulky or heavy.

If I had to find a flaw, the water resistance is more splash-proof than fully waterproof, so heavy rain might still sneak in. Also, the lack of multiple compartments makes organization a bit of a challenge if you carry a lot.

Still, for the price, it’s an excellent little travel buddy.

What Features Define the Best Waterproof Foldable Backpack?

The best waterproof foldable backpacks are characterized by several key features that enhance their functionality and durability.

  • Waterproof Material: The most essential feature is the use of high-quality waterproof materials such as ripstop nylon or coated polyester, which prevent water from seeping in. This ensures that your belongings stay dry even in heavy rain or when exposed to water, making it ideal for outdoor activities.
  • Lightweight Design: A good foldable backpack should be lightweight to ensure comfort during long hikes or travel. This feature allows travelers to carry the backpack without adding unnecessary weight, making it easy to fold and store when not in use.
  • Compact and Foldable: The ability to fold down into a small size for easy storage is crucial for a foldable backpack. This feature allows users to pack it away in their luggage or a larger bag, making it convenient for spontaneous trips or as an extra bag for day outings.
  • Multiple Compartments: Having several compartments or pockets helps in organizing gear and personal items efficiently. This feature allows users to separate wet clothes from dry ones and keep smaller items accessible, enhancing overall usability.
  • Adjustable Straps: Adjustable and padded shoulder straps provide comfort and ensure the backpack fits well on different body types. This feature is important for maintaining comfort during prolonged use, especially when carrying heavier loads.
  • Durable Zippers and Seams: High-quality zippers that are waterproof or water-resistant, along with reinforced seams, contribute to the overall durability of the backpack. This feature helps in preventing water from entering through the openings and ensures that the backpack withstands rough handling.
  • Reflective Elements: Reflective strips or logos improve visibility during low-light conditions, making it safer for night use. This feature is particularly useful for hikers or cyclists who may find themselves outdoors after dark.

How Does Waterproof Material Affect Durability?

Waterproof materials significantly enhance the durability of foldable backpacks by providing resistance to water damage and environmental wear.

  • Material Composition: Waterproof foldable backpacks are typically made from materials such as nylon, polyester, or PVC, which are treated with waterproof coatings. These materials not only repel water but also resist tearing and abrasion, making them ideal for outdoor activities.
  • Seam Sealing: The seams of waterproof backpacks are often sealed or welded to prevent water from seeping through. This additional layer of protection enhances the overall durability by ensuring that even under heavy rain, the contents remain dry and the backpack itself is less likely to suffer from water-related wear.
  • Durability Under Stress: Waterproof materials tend to have higher tensile strength, meaning they can withstand stretching and pulling without tearing. This quality is essential for foldable backpacks, which need to maintain their shape and functionality despite being packed tightly or carried over long distances.
  • Resistance to Mold and Mildew: Water-resistant materials help prevent the growth of mold and mildew, which can degrade the fabric over time. By keeping moisture at bay, these materials contribute to a longer lifespan for the backpack, ensuring it remains in good condition after repeated use.
  • UV Resistance: Many waterproof materials are also treated with UV inhibitors, protecting the fabric from sun damage. This feature is crucial for maintaining color and integrity, especially for backpacks exposed to sunlight during outdoor adventures.

Why is Weight Consideration Important in Foldable Backpacks?

The underlying mechanism involves biomechanics; when a backpack is heavy, it can lead to poor posture and increased fatigue, which may result in discomfort or even injury. A foldable backpack that is both lightweight and waterproof allows users to pack efficiently without the added burden of a heavy bag, encouraging longer and more enjoyable excursions. Furthermore, lightweight materials often used in waterproof foldable backpacks, such as ripstop nylon, are designed to provide durability without excess weight, making them a preferred choice for travelers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

What Are the Advantages of Choosing a Waterproof Foldable Backpack?

The advantages of choosing a waterproof foldable backpack are numerous, making it a practical choice for various activities.

  • Water Resistance: A waterproof foldable backpack is designed to keep your belongings dry, even in heavy rain or wet environments. This is especially beneficial for outdoor enthusiasts who may encounter unpredictable weather during hikes, camping trips, or water sports.
  • Portability: These backpacks are lightweight and can be easily folded into a compact size, making them convenient for travel. You can pack them in your luggage or carry them in your bag, ensuring you have extra storage available whenever needed.
  • Durability: Made from high-quality materials, waterproof foldable backpacks are often resistant to tears and abrasions, providing long-lasting use. This durability ensures that they can withstand the rigors of outdoor activities without compromising their integrity.
  • Versatility: Waterproof foldable backpacks come in various sizes and designs, suitable for different occasions, from day hikes to beach trips. Their multifunctional nature allows them to be used as a daypack, shopping bag, or even a gym bag.
  • Easy Maintenance: These backpacks usually require minimal care; they can be wiped clean or rinsed off without damaging their waterproof features. This ease of maintenance is a considerable advantage for those who lead an active lifestyle and need a reliable bag without the hassle of frequent cleaning.

How Can a Foldable Backpack Enhance Travel Convenience?

A foldable backpack can significantly enhance travel convenience through its practicality and versatility.

  • Space-Saving Design: Foldable backpacks are designed to be compact and lightweight, allowing them to be easily stored in luggage or carried in a larger bag when not in use.
  • Waterproof Material: The best waterproof foldable backpacks are made from materials that repel water, ensuring that your belongings stay dry during unexpected rain showers or spills.
  • Multi-Purpose Use: These backpacks can serve various functions, from day trips to shopping, making them a versatile addition to any travel gear.
  • Durability: Despite their lightweight nature, many foldable backpacks are constructed with durable materials that withstand wear and tear, ensuring long-lasting use.
  • Easy to Clean: The materials used in foldable backpacks often make them easy to clean, allowing travelers to maintain hygiene without hassle.

Foldable backpacks are designed to be compact and lightweight, allowing them to be easily stored in luggage or carried in a larger bag when not in use. This feature is particularly advantageous for travelers who need to maximize space without sacrificing convenience.

The best waterproof foldable backpacks are made from materials that repel water, ensuring that your belongings stay dry during unexpected rain showers or spills. This waterproof quality not only protects valuables but also adds peace of mind when traveling in diverse weather conditions.

These backpacks can serve various functions, from day trips to shopping, making them a versatile addition to any travel gear. Their adaptability means they can easily transition from a casual day pack to a functional shopping bag, catering to different travel scenarios.

Despite their lightweight nature, many foldable backpacks are constructed with durable materials that withstand wear and tear, ensuring long-lasting use. This durability is crucial for travelers who engage in outdoor activities or need a reliable bag for everyday adventures.

The materials used in foldable backpacks often make them easy to clean, allowing travelers to maintain hygiene without hassle. This feature is essential for those who frequently encounter dirt or mud while exploring new destinations.

What Makes Waterproofing Essential for Outdoor Activities?

  • Protection Against Rain: Waterproofing keeps your belongings dry during unexpected downpours, allowing you to enjoy outdoor activities without worrying about wet gear.
  • Durability: Waterproof materials tend to be more robust, resisting wear and tear from environmental factors like moisture, dirt, and UV rays, which prolongs the life of your backpack.
  • Versatility: A waterproof foldable backpack can serve multiple purposes, from hiking and camping to beach outings, making it a practical choice for various adventures.
  • Easy Maintenance: Waterproof backpacks are generally easier to clean and maintain, as dirt and stains can be wiped off without damaging the material, ensuring your gear stays looking new.
  • Peace of Mind: Knowing your belongings are safe from water damage provides a sense of security, allowing you to focus on enjoying your outdoor activities rather than worrying about the weather.

Protection Against Rain: Waterproofing keeps your belongings dry during unexpected downpours, allowing you to enjoy outdoor activities without worrying about wet gear. It is especially important for items like electronics, clothing, and food that can be severely damaged by moisture.

Durability: Waterproof materials tend to be more robust, resisting wear and tear from environmental factors like moisture, dirt, and UV rays, which prolongs the life of your backpack. This durability makes waterproof foldable backpacks ideal for rugged adventures where exposure to the elements is inevitable.

Versatility: A waterproof foldable backpack can serve multiple purposes, from hiking and camping to beach outings, making it a practical choice for various adventures. Its ability to fold and store easily adds convenience, allowing users to carry it in their main luggage without taking up much space.

Easy Maintenance: Waterproof backpacks are generally easier to clean and maintain, as dirt and stains can be wiped off without damaging the material, ensuring your gear stays looking new. This is particularly beneficial for outdoor enthusiasts who frequently find themselves in muddy or sandy environments.

Peace of Mind: Knowing your belongings are safe from water damage provides a sense of security, allowing you to focus on enjoying your outdoor activities rather than worrying about the weather. This peace of mind is invaluable during long treks or trips where gear replacement options may be limited.

What Should Users Look for in Reviews of Waterproof Foldable Backpacks?

When seeking reviews of waterproof foldable backpacks, users should focus on several key aspects that affect functionality and usability.

  • Waterproof Rating: Look for reviews that mention the backpack’s waterproof rating, typically indicated by IPX ratings or material specifications. A higher rating signifies better resistance to water, ensuring your belongings stay dry in various conditions.
  • Material Quality: The type of material used in the backpack can greatly influence its durability and waterproof capabilities. High-quality fabrics like nylon or polyester with waterproof coatings are ideal, as they offer both strength and water resistance.
  • Comfort and Fit: Reviews should address how comfortable the backpack is during use, particularly factors like strap padding and back support. A comfortable fit is essential for long-term wear, especially when carrying heavier loads.
  • Foldability and Portability: An important feature of foldable backpacks is how easily they can be packed down for storage or travel. Users should look for reviews that discuss the size and weight of the backpack when folded, as well as any additional features that enhance portability.
  • Storage Capacity: Consider the storage options provided, such as the number of compartments and pockets. Reviews that detail how much the backpack can hold, while maintaining a compact profile, will help users assess its practicality for their needs.
  • Customer Support and Warranty: Check for information regarding the manufacturer’s customer support and any warranties offered. A solid warranty can provide peace of mind regarding the backpack’s durability and the company’s commitment to quality.
  • User Experience: Pay attention to user testimonials regarding their real-world experiences with the backpack. Insights into how the backpack performs under various conditions can provide a clearer picture of its reliability and functionality.

How Do Different Brands and Models Compare in the Market?

Brand Model Price Features Rating Weight Color Options Warranty
Brand A Model X $45 Lightweight, 20L capacity, water-resistant zippers 4.5/5 0.5 lbs Black, Blue, Red 1 year
Brand B Model Y $60 Durable fabric, 25L capacity, includes rain cover 4.7/5 1.0 lbs Green, Grey, Orange 2 years
Brand C Model Z $50 Compact design, 15L capacity, adjustable straps 4.3/5 0.6 lbs Pink, Purple, Black 1 year

What Maintenance Tips Help Ensure Longevity for Waterproof Foldable Backpacks?

To ensure longevity for waterproof foldable backpacks, consider the following maintenance tips:

  • Regular Cleaning: Clean your backpack regularly to remove dirt and grime that can wear down the fabric.
  • Avoid Overloading: Be mindful of the weight you put in your backpack to prevent stress on the seams and zippers.
  • Proper Storage: Store your backpack in a cool, dry place when not in use to prevent mold and mildew.
  • Waterproofing Maintenance: Reapply waterproofing treatments as needed to maintain the fabric’s water resistance.
  • Inspect for Damage: Regularly check for any signs of wear and tear, such as frayed straps or broken zippers, and address them promptly.

Regular cleaning involves using mild soap and water to wipe down the exterior and interior surfaces, which helps to preserve the material and keep it looking new. Make sure to rinse thoroughly and allow it to air dry completely before storing it away.

Avoid overloading by adhering to the manufacturer’s weight recommendation, as exceeding this limit can lead to structural damage over time, including stretched seams and compromised waterproofing. Distributing weight evenly can also help maintain the backpack’s shape and functionality.

Proper storage is essential; keeping the backpack in a dry, ventilated area protects it from humidity that can cause mold and mildew growth. Avoid placing it in direct sunlight for prolonged periods, as UV rays can degrade the fabric.

Waterproofing maintenance is crucial for preserving the backpack’s functionality; consider using a spray-on waterproofing agent designed for outdoor fabrics. This should be done periodically, especially after washing the backpack or if it has been subjected to heavy rain.

Inspecting for damage regularly allows for timely repairs, reducing the chance of further deterioration. Addressing small issues, like sewing up a small hole or replacing a broken zipper, can significantly extend the lifespan of your backpack.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment