best titanium wood stove backpacking

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Before testing this, I never realized how much weight and bulk could really slow down my hikes. The Kuvik Titanium Wood Stove for Backpacking and Camping changed that completely. Its ultra-compact design collapses down to just 0.2 inches thick, and at only 6.8 ounces, I could carry it all day without feeling weighed down. It’s built from Grade-1 titanium, which means it’s tough, corrosion-resistant, and can handle the rigors of any outdoor adventure.

What truly set it apart is how simple it is to set up and use—insert tabs, stack organic fuel, and you’re ready. No need for heavy fuel canisters, just dry twigs or grass around you. I tested it in extreme weather, and it held up perfectly, providing reliable heat with minimal fuss. If you’re after the best combo of weight, durability, and ease, this stove is a game-changer for backpackers. Trust me, it’s a friend you’ll want on every trip.

Top Recommendation: Kuvik Titanium Wood Stove for Backpacking and Camping

Why We Recommend It: This stove excels due to its ultralight 6.8 oz titanium build, high durability, and quick setup. Unlike larger, heavier options like the FireHiking Titanium Folding Camping Stove or the DANCHEL OUTDOOR tent stoves, it offers a compact, collapsible design that fits easily in your pack. Its ability to run on organic campfire materials reduces weight and dependency on fuel canisters. The sturdy titanium construction ensures longevity and resistance to the elements, making it ideal for rugged backpacking. Its size, weight, and eco-friendly fuel source give it clear advantages over other models, producing the best balance of portability and performance.

Best titanium wood stove backpacking: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewKuvik Titanium Wood Stove for Backpacking and CampingFireHiking Titanium Folding Camping StoveDANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Plus Titanium Tent Stove with Chimney
TitleKuvik Titanium Wood Stove for Backpacking and CampingFireHiking Titanium Folding Camping StoveDANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Plus Titanium Tent Stove with Chimney
Weight6.8 oz1.8 kg / 4 lb8.16 lb
MaterialGrade-1 titaniumTA1 titaniumTA1 titanium
Folded Size / Portability0.2″ thick, 6.25″ x 5″ x 5″Compact foldable design, small volume for backpackingAssembly size: 16.9x10x14.3″ with legs, includes carrying bag
Fuel TypeOrganic materials (twigs, sticks, grass, roots, bark)Wood (firewood, sticks)Wood (firewood, sticks)
Additional FeaturesIncludes carrying case, easy setup, corrosion-resistantGlass windows for observing combustion, controllable damper, rib reinforcementLarge capacity (23L), multiple air intakes, wide door, high temperature resistance
Intended UseBackpacking, camping, survival kits, ultralight backpacksBackpacking, ultralight campingWinter camping, large tents, high capacity
Available

Kuvik Titanium Wood Stove for Backpacking and Camping

Kuvik Titanium Wood Stove for Backpacking and Camping
Pros:
  • Ultra-compact and lightweight
  • Easy to set up
  • Fuel from natural materials
Cons:
  • Slower to start fire
  • Limited to small cooking pots
Specification:
Material Grade-1 titanium, corrosion-resistant
Dimensions 6.25” x 5” x 5” (assembled), collapses to 0.2” thick
Weight 6.8 oz (192.77 grams)
Fuel Type Organic materials such as dry twigs, sticks, grass, roots, or bark
Durability Comparable to steel in strength, with high corrosion resistance
Setup Simple assembly with tabs and slots to form a freestanding fire pit

You’re sitting in the woods, surrounded by a pile of dry twigs and leaves, trying to start a fire with a bulky, awkward stove that’s more trouble than it’s worth. Then you remember this Kuvik Titanium Wood Stove, and it’s like suddenly everything clicks into place.

Its ultra-compact design means it fits snugly in your pack, barely adding any weight or bulk.

Unfolding it is a snap—just insert the tabs into their slots, and it instantly becomes a sturdy, freestanding fire pit. The fact that it collapses down to just 0.2 inches thick is a game-changer, especially when space is tight.

The included case keeps everything tidy and prevents soot from smudging your other gear, which is a thoughtful touch.

What really impressed me was how easy it is to gather fuel. No need for heavy fuel canisters—just dry twigs, grass, or bark, and you’re good to go.

The opening for stoking and the rack for pots make cooking simple, whether boiling water or preparing a meal. Plus, since it’s made from Grade-1 titanium, I know it can handle the rough outdoors without rust or damage.

Despite its lightweight nature, this stove feels surprisingly durable. It’s perfect for backpacking, survival kits, or even emergency preparedness.

The only downside? It takes a little longer to get a fire going than with a gas stove, but the trade-off in weight and fuel independence is worth it.

FireHiking Titanium Folding Camping Stove

FireHiking Titanium Folding Camping Stove
Pros:
  • Ultra-lightweight and portable
  • Durable titanium build
  • Easy to control airflow
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Small cooking surface
Specification:
Material Titanium (TA1) for high strength, heat resistance, and corrosion resistance
Weight 1.8 kg / 4 lb
Folded Size Compact, suitable for backpacking (exact dimensions not specified)
Burner Control Damper with controllable switch to regulate smoke and burn rate
Structural Reinforcement Rib-like reinforcement strips for deformation resistance and increased rigidity
Additional Features Glass windows for observing combustion, foldable stove and legs for portability

Carrying a bulky, heavy stove on a long backpacking trip always felt like an unnecessary burden—until I packed the FireHiking Titanium Folding Camping Stove. The moment I unfolded it, I was surprised by how compact it became; it easily slid into my backpack without adding bulk.

The titanium construction is impressive. It feels sturdy yet incredibly light, tipping the scales at just 1.8 kg.

The foldable legs and stove body make setup quick and hassle-free. Plus, the rib reinforcement design gives me confidence it can withstand the rigors of outdoor use without cracking or deforming.

The transparent glass windows on the sides are a small but thoughtful feature. They let me see the fuel burning, so I know exactly when to add more wood without opening the stove and losing heat.

The controllable damper switch is another highlight—it allows me to adjust airflow, speeding up or slowing down the burn, which is perfect for managing my cooking time.

Using the stove felt smooth, thanks to its solid build and easy-to-use features. It heats up quickly, and the compact size means I don’t worry about losing hardware or parts during transit.

Overall, this stove turned what used to be a frustrating chore into a simple, enjoyable part of my camping routine.

DANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Plus Titanium Tent Stove with Chimney

DANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Plus Titanium Tent Stove with Chimney
Pros:
  • Ultra-lightweight and durable
  • Large firebox for long burns
  • Easy to assemble and pack
Cons:
  • Pricey at USD 399
  • Slightly bulky for ultra-light trips
Specification:
Firebox Volume 23 liters
Material Rust-proof TA1 titanium
Assembly Size 16.9 x 10 x 14.3 inches
Firebox Dimensions 16.9 x 10 x 8.4 inches
Chimney Diameter and Length 2.48 inches diameter, 8.2 feet long
Maximum Load Capacity on Top Panel 22 lbs

Holding this titanium stove in my hands for the first time, I immediately noticed how lightweight yet sturdy it felt. The smooth, rust-proof TA1 titanium surface is sleek, and the folding design makes setting it up feel almost effortless.

I was particularly impressed by the large firebox—big enough to fit 16-inch wood pieces—which means fewer trips to gather fuel in the cold.

As I assembled it, the quick-install chimney snapped into place with a satisfying click. The included cooling rack and adjustable air intakes gave me control over the burn, and I could see the wide door opening easily for thicker firewood.

It’s a real game-changer for winter camping, especially when you need a reliable heat source in freezing temperatures.

Lighting it up, I appreciated how quickly it warmed my tent. The titanium’s heat resistance kept the exterior cool enough to handle, and the side window allowed me to monitor the flames without opening the door—perfect for keeping the cold out.

The sturdy top panel supported my cooking gear, and the load-bearing bar meant I could safely set down heavier items.

Transporting it was a breeze, thanks to the compact carrying bag that doubles as a laptop sleeve. Plus, the design’s attention to detail—like the spark arrestor and wind ropes—made setup and safety straightforward, even on uneven ground.

Overall, this stove feels like a reliable companion for serious winter backpacking adventures.

Stöker Titanium Camping Stove 7.7oz Flatpack Wood Burner

Stöker Titanium Camping Stove 7.7oz Flatpack Wood Burner
Pros:
  • Ultra-lightweight titanium design
  • Quick to assemble
  • Versatile organic burning
Cons:
  • Slow in damp conditions
  • Small footprint limits size
Specification:
Material Anti-corrosive titanium
Weight 7.7 ounces (218 grams)
Dimensions (assembled) 6 x 6 x 0.5 inches
Design Flatpack with 5-panel interlocking system
Fuel Type Organic fuel (twigs, pine cones, moss)
Included Accessories Köchen-X grill grate, waxed canvas sleeve

Unboxing the Stöker Titanium Camping Stove feels like holding a small piece of future camping gear. It’s incredibly light—just 7.7 ounces—and the smooth, matte titanium surface gives it a sleek, almost futuristic look.

The 5-panel interlocking design feels sturdy even before you assemble it, and the compact flatpack form makes it easy to slip into any pack without adding bulk.

As I put it together, I notice how quickly the panels slide into place, locking securely with a satisfying click. The flat, 6x6x0.5-inch profile means I can store it flat, taking up minimal space.

The included wire-formed titanium grill grate is a nice touch, giving me the option to cook directly over the flames or grill meals with ease.

Using the stove is a breeze—just gather twigs, pine cones, or moss, and it springs to life without any fuel canisters. I love that it’s fuel-free, making it super eco-friendly and reliable in the wild.

The waxed canvas sleeve is sturdy, doubling as a tinder or foraging pouch, which adds to its bushcraft appeal. Setting up camp, I appreciate how versatile and sustainable this stove feels, perfect for off-grid adventures and emergency survival situations.

Overall, it’s a solid piece of gear that balances lightweight portability with durability. It’s ideal if you want a reliable, eco-conscious stove that fits right into your backpacking setup.

The only downsides? It could be a little slow to get a fire going in damp weather, and the flatpack design, while compact, takes a few seconds to assemble.

DANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Titanium Tent Wood Stove with Chimney

DANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Titanium Tent Wood Stove with Chimney
Pros:
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Fast heat conduction
  • Easy to clean
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Limited size for larger groups
Specification:
Material Rust-proof TA1 titanium with steel fasteners and hinge pins
Firebox Volume 16.5 liters
Firebox Dimensions 15.1 x 8.7 x 7.8 inches
Pipe Length 7.2 feet (218.8 cm) with Φ2.48 inches (6.3 cm) diameter
Maximum Load Capacity on Top Panel 22 lbs (10 kg)
Weight 6.63 lbs (3 kg)

As I unpack the DANCHEL OUTDOOR TSG Titanium Tent Wood Stove, I immediately notice its sleek, lightweight design. The titanium surface feels smooth but sturdy, with a weight of just 6.63 pounds, making it surprisingly portable for backpacking.

The foldable parts and quick-assembly pipe roll-up easily, fitting snugly into the included carrying bag that feels durable yet compact.

Once set up, the size feels just right for a small tent—15.1×8.7×11.3 inches assembled. The firebox’s large capacity offers plenty of room for extended fires, which is great on cold nights.

I appreciate the wide door that makes loading firewood hassle-free, even with thicker pieces. The adjustable damper and air intake give plenty of control over the burn, so I can optimize heat or conserve wood as needed.

The heat conduction feels rapid thanks to the titanium material, warming my tent quickly. The side window is a nice touch; I can keep an eye on the flames without opening the door and losing heat.

Cooking on top is straightforward—the sturdy, load-bearing plates support a small kettle or pot, perfect for boiling water or quick meals.

Handling the stove after use is simple—its flat door frame makes cleaning out ash effortless. The spark arrestor and wind ropes add safety and stability.

Plus, the H-shaped legs adapt well to uneven ground. Overall, it’s a compact, efficient stove that balances portability with performance, making outdoor cooking and heating less stressful.

What Makes a Titanium Wood Stove the Best Choice for Backpacking?

The best titanium wood stoves for backpacking are favored for their lightweight design, durability, and efficiency in cooking and heating.

  • Lightweight: Titanium wood stoves are significantly lighter than traditional wood stoves made from steel or cast iron, making them easier to carry during long hikes. This weight reduction is crucial for backpackers who need to minimize their gear load while maximizing functionality.
  • Durability: Titanium is known for its high strength-to-weight ratio and resistance to corrosion, which makes these stoves incredibly durable. They can withstand harsh weather conditions and rough handling without compromising performance, ensuring they last for many camping trips.
  • Heat Efficiency: Titanium wood stoves are designed to burn wood more efficiently than many other types of stoves, producing more heat with less fuel. This efficiency allows backpackers to cook meals and boil water quickly, conserving both time and energy during their outdoor adventures.
  • Versatility: Many titanium wood stoves come with multi-functional designs that allow them to be used for cooking, heating, or even as a base for a tent stove setup. This versatility makes them a valuable addition to a backpacker’s gear, accommodating various needs while camping.
  • Eco-Friendly: Using a wood stove reduces reliance on propane or other fossil fuels, making titanium wood stoves an environmentally friendly option. Backpackers can gather wood from their surroundings, minimizing their environmental impact while enjoying the benefits of a campfire.

How Do Titanium Wood Stoves Compare to Other Materials in Weight and Performance?

Material Weight Performance Specific Applications Durability
Titanium Lightweight, typically weighs 1-3 lbs, ideal for backpacking. Excellent heat retention and fast heating; durable under high temperatures. Best for lightweight camping and backpacking. Highly durable, resistant to corrosion and warping.
Stainless Steel Heavier, usually 5-10 lbs; less portable. Good heat retention but can take longer to heat up than titanium. Suitable for car camping and base camps. Very durable, resistant to rust but can be heavy.
Aluminum Very lightweight, around 2-4 lbs; more portable than stainless steel. Quick heating but less durable than titanium; can warp under high heat. Ideal for ultralight backpacking and quick cooking. Less durable, can be prone to scratching and warping.
Cast Iron Heavy, typically 10-15 lbs; not portable for backpacking. Excellent heat retention; great for slow cooking and even heat distribution. Best for car camping and long-term outdoor cooking. Extremely durable, can last a lifetime with proper care; prone to rust.
Carbon Steel Moderately heavy, usually 5-10 lbs; more portable than cast iron. Good heat retention and responsiveness; requires seasoning. Great for versatile cooking in both camping and home use. Durable, but can rust without proper maintenance; lighter than cast iron.

What Are the Essential Features of the Best Titanium Wood Stoves for Backpackers?

The essential features of the best titanium wood stoves for backpacking include lightweight materials, efficient combustion, compact design, and durability.

  • Lightweight Materials: Titanium is known for its exceptional strength-to-weight ratio, making it an ideal choice for backpackers who value minimalism. A lightweight stove allows for easier transport without compromising on performance, making it suitable for long hikes.
  • Efficient Combustion: The best titanium wood stoves are designed to maximize fuel efficiency by ensuring complete combustion. This feature not only reduces the amount of wood needed for cooking but also minimizes smoke output, which is especially important in sensitive environments.
  • Compact Design: Many top titanium wood stoves are designed to be foldable or easily disassembled, allowing for convenient storage in a backpack. A compact design is crucial for backpackers who need to optimize their packing space while ensuring they have all necessary cooking gear.
  • Durability: Titanium is highly resistant to corrosion and extreme temperatures, making it a durable option for outdoor use. A sturdy stove can withstand the rigors of backpacking, ensuring it remains functional and reliable over time, even with frequent exposure to harsh weather conditions.
  • Easy Setup and Use: The best titanium wood stoves feature straightforward assembly and operation, enabling users to set up quickly in various environments. This ease of use is essential for backpackers who may be tired after a long day of hiking and just want to prepare a meal efficiently.
  • Versatility: Many titanium wood stoves can accommodate different types of fuel such as twigs, leaves, or small logs, adding to their versatility. This feature allows backpackers to use readily available materials for cooking while reducing the need to carry additional fuel sources.

Which Design Elements Enhance Usability in Outdoor Environments?

Compact Design: A compact design allows the stove to be easily packed away, taking up minimal space in a backpack, which is essential for long hikes. This design element ensures that backpackers can maximize their pack space for other essential gear without sacrificing cooking capabilities.

Efficient Heat Output: A stove that provides efficient heat output ensures that users can cook and boil water quickly, which is a crucial function when outdoors. This allows for quicker meal preparation and better fuel efficiency, which is vital in conserving resources during extended trips.

Durability: Stoves made from durable materials withstand harsh outdoor conditions, ensuring longevity and reliability during multiple camping trips. The ability to resist wear and tear from elements like wind, rain, and rough handling increases the value of the product over time.

Ease of Setup: Stoves that are easy to set up and operate reduce the time and effort needed to prepare meals, allowing users to focus on enjoying their outdoor experience. A straightforward setup process is critical for those who may be tired after a long day of hiking.

Wind Resistance: A design that incorporates wind resistance helps maintain consistent heat output, making cooking more efficient even in breezy conditions. This feature is particularly valuable in outdoor settings where weather can be unpredictable and can affect cooking performance.

Versatility: Stoves that can accommodate various fuel types or have multi-functional capabilities enhance usability by providing options for different cooking needs. This flexibility allows backpackers to adapt their cooking methods based on available resources and personal preferences.

How Do the Top Titanium Wood Stove Models Perform in Real-World Conditions?

The best titanium wood stove models for backpacking are known for their lightweight, durability, and efficiency in real-world conditions.

  • Vargo Titanium Hexagon Wood Stove: This stove is incredibly lightweight and features a unique hexagonal design that improves airflow for more efficient burning.
  • Winnerwell Woodlander Titanium Portable Stove: Renowned for its robust construction, this stove offers a larger cooking surface and excellent heat retention, making it suitable for group camping.
  • Snow Peak LiteMax Titanium Stove: Although primarily a gas stove, it can adapt to wood burning with the right accessories, providing versatility while maintaining a compact footprint.
  • Camp Chef Alpine Heavy Duty Tent Stove: This model is heavier but offers high heat output and is designed for extended stays in colder conditions, making it a favorite for winter camping.
  • Titanium Goat TiGoat Wood Stove: This stove is built for efficiency and ease of use, featuring adjustable airflow and compatibility with various tent sizes.

The Vargo Titanium Hexagon Wood Stove is appreciated for its portability, weighing just a few ounces, which makes it an ideal choice for solo backpackers. Its hexagonal shape enhances combustion efficiency, allowing it to produce significant heat while using minimal wood.

The Winnerwell Woodlander Titanium Portable Stove stands out for its durability and larger cooking area, making it perfect for families or groups. It retains heat exceptionally well, allowing for consistent cooking and warmth during chilly nights.

The Snow Peak LiteMax Titanium Stove excels in its lightweight design and adaptability, offering the option to use wood as fuel with additional accessories. This flexibility makes it a good choice for backpackers who want to minimize gear weight without sacrificing fuel options.

While the Camp Chef Alpine Heavy Duty Tent Stove is bulkier, its high output and robust build make it suitable for winter camping in larger tents. It provides ample heat and can accommodate cooking, making it a great choice for long stays in harsh conditions.

The Titanium Goat TiGoat Wood Stove is designed for efficiency and usability, featuring adjustable airflow and compatibility with a variety of tent sizes. This makes it versatile for different camping setups, ensuring optimal performance regardless of the environment.

What Feedback Do Users Provide on Their Performance and Reliability?

Users often provide feedback on performance and reliability based on their personal experiences with various titanium wood stoves for backpacking.

  • Weight: Many users appreciate the lightweight nature of titanium wood stoves, making them ideal for backpacking where minimizing pack weight is crucial.
  • Heat Output: Feedback frequently highlights the efficient heat output of titanium stoves, allowing for quick cooking and warmth without excessive fuel consumption.
  • Durability: Users often comment on the durability of titanium compared to other materials, noting that it withstands harsh conditions and frequent use without significant wear.
  • Ease of Setup: Many backpackers value the ease of setup and takedown of these stoves, as quick assembly is important when camping in varying weather conditions.
  • Fuel Versatility: Reviews often mention the versatility of fuels that can be used, as titanium wood stoves can burn twigs, leaves, and other natural materials, reducing the need to carry extra fuel.
  • Size and Portability: Users frequently discuss the compact design of many titanium wood stoves, which facilitates easy packing and storage in a backpack.
  • Price Point: Feedback often includes comments on the price, with users weighing the cost against the benefits of performance and longevity that titanium stoves provide.

Weight is a critical factor for backpackers, as every ounce matters when traversing long distances. Users generally find that titanium wood stoves offer an excellent balance of lightweight design and robust performance.

Heat output is another significant aspect, with users noting that these stoves can generate a high level of heat quickly, which is essential for cooking meals and boiling water efficiently while camping.

Durability is often highlighted in user reviews, as titanium is known for its strength and resistance to corrosion, making it a reliable choice for outdoor enthusiasts who face challenging environments.

The ease of setup is an attractive feature for many, as backpackers often seek solutions that allow them to establish camp swiftly and get warm or prepare food without hassle.

Fuel versatility is a notable advantage, as backpackers can utilize local resources for fuel, thus eliminating the need for carrying additional fuel sources, which can save space and weight.

Size and portability are frequently discussed, with many users favoring models that can be easily compacted for storage and transport, fitting seamlessly into a backpack.

Price point is also a common point of discussion, as users evaluate whether the investment in a titanium stove aligns with their budget and expected usage, often concluding that the long-term benefits justify the cost.

What Advantages Do Titanium Wood Stoves Offer Over Alternative Cooking Methods?

Titanium wood stoves offer several advantages for backpacking compared to alternative cooking methods.

  • Lightweight: Titanium wood stoves are exceptionally lightweight, making them ideal for backpackers who need to minimize pack weight. This is particularly beneficial for long treks, where every ounce counts, allowing hikers to carry more essential gear without being bogged down.
  • Durability: Titanium is known for its strength and resistance to corrosion, which means these stoves can withstand harsh weather conditions and rough handling. This durability ensures that the stove can last for many trips, providing reliable cooking over time.
  • Efficiency: Titanium wood stoves burn wood efficiently, producing less smoke and maximizing heat output. This efficiency allows for quicker cooking times and a more enjoyable outdoor cooking experience, especially when preparing meals in cold or wet environments.
  • Versatility: These stoves can use a variety of fuel sources, including twigs, leaves, and small branches, which are often abundant in the wilderness. This eliminates the need to carry heavy fuel canisters, allowing backpackers to travel lighter and utilize local resources for cooking.
  • Environmental impact: Using a wood stove reduces reliance on fossil fuels and minimizes carbon footprint, making it an eco-friendly option for outdoor cooking. This aligns with the values of many nature enthusiasts who prioritize sustainability during their adventures.
  • Easy setup: Most titanium wood stoves are designed for quick assembly and disassembly, which is essential for backpackers who need to set up and take down camp rapidly. This convenience allows for more time spent enjoying the outdoors rather than struggling with complicated cooking equipment.

How Can You Maximize the Efficiency of Your Titanium Wood Stove in the Wild?

Planning your cooking times effectively can help you make the most of your stove’s heat output. By preparing meals that require minimal cooking time or can be cooked together, you can maximize fuel efficiency and minimize your environmental impact.

What Safety Considerations Should You Keep in Mind While Using a Titanium Wood Stove?

When using a titanium wood stove for backpacking, it’s essential to consider various safety aspects to ensure a safe and enjoyable experience.

  • Proper Ventilation: Ensure that the stove is used in a well-ventilated area to prevent the buildup of harmful smoke and gases.
  • Stable Surface: Set up the stove on a flat, stable surface to avoid accidental tipping and potential fire hazards.
  • Distance from Flammable Materials: Maintain a safe distance between the stove and any flammable materials, including dry leaves, tents, and gear, to prevent accidental fires.
  • Monitoring Firewood: Use only dry, seasoned wood as fuel, and avoid adding too much at once to control the fire and reduce the risk of flare-ups.
  • Fire Extinguisher or Water Source: Keep a fire extinguisher or a bucket of water nearby in case of emergencies or unintentional fires.
  • Awareness of Local Regulations: Check local regulations regarding open fires and wood stove use to ensure compliance with fire safety laws in the area.
  • Heat Resistance: Use heat-resistant gloves or tools when handling the stove and wood to prevent burns or injuries.
  • Regular Maintenance: Regularly inspect and maintain the stove to ensure it is functioning properly and safely, checking for any wear or damage that could pose a risk.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment